Water Heater Repair Vs. Replacement: How to Decide

Water Heater Repair Vs. Replacement: How to Decide

If you’ve ever experienced a sudden drop in water temperature during your morning shower or noticed strange noises from your trusty old water heater, you’re not alone. Homeowners rely heavily on water heaters for daily activities, such as showering, dishwashing, and laundry. So, when faced with issues, it’s crucial to assess whether a repair will suffice or if it’s time to consider a replacement. In this comprehensive guide, we’ll help you navigate the decision-making process by exploring the factors to consider when weighing repair versus replacement options for your water heater.

Signs That Indicate Your Water Heater Needs Attention


Is there a puddle of water underneath your water heater? Don’t put off calling a water heater repair expert; this could be a sign of a severe problem. While leaks are usually fixable, it may be necessary to replace the heater on rare occasions.

Temperature Fluctuations

Though “no hot water at all” might be the most obvious sign of trouble, temperature fluctuations are also concerning. It could indicate that the heating elements in your water heater need to be changed or serviced due to mineral buildup.

You Constantly Run Out of Hot Water

If hot water runs out more quickly than usual, something is amiss with the burner or element in your water heater. When the hot water suddenly turns cold, it’s a warning sign that shouldn’t be ignored.

Noisy Operation

Your water heater is a major appliance, so it is certain to make some noise. But you contact a water heater repair expert if it makes popping, slamming, or cracking noises. The appliance probably overheated due to the accumulation of mineral deposits as it worked to maintain a constant water temperature. If the tank hasn’t started leaking, flushing and cleaning it well might be enough to keep it functional.

Low Water Pressure

Low water pressure is one of the most noticeable effects of mineral deposits on a water heater. These deposits can cause pipe blockages if they accumulate in the heating elements. As a result, the water coming out of the water heater is under less pressure. Additionally, water pressure decreases as a water heater ages. A plumber can fix your water heater and restore your water pressure to normal.

Benefits of Repairing Your Water Heater


Water heater repair is often a more economical option compared to outright replacement. The cost of parts and labor for repairs is typically lower than purchasing a new unit. If the issue with your water heater is relatively minor and can be fixed with a simple repair, you can save money by opting for repair instead of a replacement.

Less Disruption To Your Daily Routine

Repairing a water heater is usually quicker than a full replacement. It involves addressing the specific problem and restoring the unit’s functionality. This means you can return to enjoying hot showers and other water-dependent activities sooner without disrupting your daily routine.

Drawbacks of Repairing Your Water Heater

Some Repairs May Be Temporary

While repairing a water heater can provide a cost-effective solution in the short term, it may only sometimes address underlying issues. Certain repairs might be temporary fixes, and you may face similar problems. If your water heater is experiencing multiple problems or has a history of frequent repairs, it might indicate that a replacement is a more viable long-term solution.

Considerations For Water Heater Replacement

If its manufacturer’s warranty still protects your current water heater, the company will pay for any necessary repairs. If the warranty has expired, you should weigh the costs and benefits of fixing a damaged heater before deciding.

Below are some factors to consider:

Age Of The Heater states that tankless water heaters have a lifespan of 20 years or more, while gas water heaters typically last for ten years.

If your water heater is getting old and the repair expense is high, you should probably get a new one. Just as you wouldn’t install a brand-new engine in an old vehicle, there’s no point in spending a lot of money fixing up a water heater that’s nearing the end of its life.

Frequency of Repairs

Always run a quick cost-benefit analysis to determine if fixing or replacing your water heater is the better option whenever it breaks down. The 50% rule is one way of reaching this goal. The 50% rule suggests that if the cost to fix something is more than half the cost to replace it, it is better to get a new one.

It’s important to consider the frequency of repairs and the age of your water heater, even if the cost of those repairs doesn’t yet equal the cost of replacing your current unit. Have you had many problems with your water heater over the previous two years? Is it getting close to the end of its useful life? If that’s the case, investing additional money into fixing it may not be worthwhile.

Safety Concerns

Older water heaters may not meet current safety standards or building codes. If your water heater lacks essential safety features, such as a temperature and pressure relief valve, it poses a potential risk of scalding or explosion.


If your household’s hot water needs have increased over time, consider a water heater with a larger capacity. This ensures an ample hot water supply to meet the demands of multiple showers, appliances, or a growing family. Alternatively, explore advanced options like tankless water heaters or heat pump systems, which offer benefits such as endless hot water, space-saving design, and energy efficiency.

Make the Right Decision: Upgrade Your Water Heater for Endless Comfort and Savings!

You must consider several factors when deciding between water heater repair or replacement. Repairing your water heater can be a cost-effective solution for minor issues and can extend the lifespan of your unit. However, replacing it can provide energy efficiency, cost savings, and greater capacity. By weighing the benefits and drawbacks of each option, you can make an informed decision that aligns with your needs and budget.

At Tioga Plumbing & Electric, we understand the importance of having a reliable and efficient water heater for your daily needs. Our team of experienced professionals can help you assess the condition of your water heater and recommend the most suitable option. We offer a range of high-quality tankless water heaters from Rinnai and provide expert installation and maintenance services to ensure your water heater runs smoothly and efficiently for years. Contact us today to schedule a consultation with our experienced professionals.

See our most recent blog on this topic here.

Check out our reviews here.

Photo By Inside Creative House at iStock
Signs You Need To Hire A Plumber Specializing In Water Heater Repair

Signs You Need To Hire A Plumber Specializing In Water Heater Repair

Can you imagine going through a whole day without hot water? You can’t take a hot shower and perform daily tasks like cooking and cleaning. Also, your dishwasher and washing machine won’t function properly. If your water heater breaks, you won’t have hot water, and some problems affect the water quality, and some can damage your home.
DIY repairs aren’t recommended because, without the necessary training, you could do further damage. Also, a DIY repair will void the warranty and won’t cover future repairs.
If your water heater develops any of the following problems, a water heater repair tech can help.

You Don’t Have Hot Water

A lack of hot water could indicate a problem with the water heater, but this isn’t always the case, so you should check a few things before hiring a plumber.

If you have an electric water heater, ensure the unit has power. If you have a propane or oil unit, make sure there’s fuel in the tank, and the pilot is lit. If your water heater runs on natural gas, ensure you have gas service, your service hasn’t been terminated, and there isn’t an outage.

If everything checks out on your end, the problem is likely with the water heater, and you should hire a plumber.

A broken heating element can prevent the unit from heating the water, and a water heater repair tech can fix the part to restore the hot water. The unit’s age can also be a factor. If it’s over ten years old, it may have reached the end of its lifespan and can no longer heat the water. If age is the cause, replacing the unit is the only way to restore the hot water.

The Water Doesn’t Get Hot Enough

When you turn on the hot water tap, you expect the water to be hot. If the water doesn’t get hotter than lukewarm, the setting on the unit’s thermostat could be the problem. If it’s set lower than 120 degrees, adjusting the thermostat will solve the problem. If the thermostat is set correctly, it’s time to hire a plumber specializing in water heater repair.

If the thermostat is defective, the water heater won’t get the correct signal, preventing the water from heating up. If your water heater has two heating elements, one may have failed, and the functional element doesn’t have the power to heat the water supply to 120 degrees. Finally, if the unit is close to ten years old, it may not be able to function efficiently any longer and can’t heat the water to the desired temperature.

The plumber will inspect the unit to determine which of these problems prevents the water from getting hot to make the necessary repair.

The Water Doesn’t Run Clear

Excellent water quality is a must because you need hot water to shower and cook, and contaminated water can affect your skin and hair and make your family sick when you cook with hot water.

If you turn on the hot water and it’s brown or rust-colored, you should hire a plumber immediately.

Sediment forms in the water tank, and if the unit isn’t regularly maintained, the sediment will build up and contaminate the water.

If your water heater is ten years old, the inside of the tank will break down, causing tiny metal shards and deposits to contaminate the water.

A plumber will determine the cause of the contamination and take the necessary steps to resolve the problem, and the water will run clear.

The Unit Sounds Like Its Possessed

Your water heater should run quietly, and you should only hear a low-level humming when standing beside the unit. If it makes strange sounds, it isn’t possessed, and the sounds you hear indicate a problem that requires a call to a plumber.

Clanging sounds indicate large pieces of sediment banging against the inside of the tank, and if you ignore the problem, the sediment can crack the tank, causing a flood.

Popping sounds indicate sediment buildup at the bottom of the tank. When water gets trapped beneath, it will boil and damage the heating element.

The plumber will try to flush the sediment, but this isn’t possible; the unit must be replaced.

Moisture or Water Around the Unit

The area around your water heater should always be dry. Moisture on or around the unit may not seem serious, but it indicates a cracked, loose or disconnected hose that can cause water damage and mold growth if not addressed quickly. Fortunately, this is a simple fix and will prevent further water damage.

A puddle of water around the tank indicates a leak in the tank, and you should cut the water supply to the unit and hire a plumber. Unfortunately, leaks can’t be fixed, and the unit must be replaced.

Reduced Hot Water Pressure

Is there a problem with the hot water pressure? If so, sediment in the tank is the culprit. When a significant amount of sediment accumulates in the tank, it will clog the waterline and reduce the water pressure, and requires a call to a plumber.

The plumber can clear the waterline, and they’ll try to flush the sediment, but if they can’t, the unit must be replaced. If you continue using your existing water heater, it won’t be long before the waterline clogs again.

Call Tioga Plumbing & Electric Today

If you need to schedule an appointment for water heater repair, look no further than Tioga Plumbing & Electric. We’re a full-service plumbing, electric and sub-contracting company, and we’ve been providing excellent service to our customers since 1953.

Our plumbers are professionally trained and have the knowledge and skill to handle any job, whether simple or complex. They’re also drug tested and must pass a background check before they’re hired.

We have someone on call 24/7, so if you have a problem that must be addressed immediately, we’re here for you any time of the day or night.

Call us today to schedule an appointment.

See our most recent blog on this topic here.

Photo By Wirestock at iStock
How a Professional Water Line Repair Service Can Save You Time and Money

How a Professional Water Line Repair Service Can Save You Time and Money

Water line repair is crucial to maintaining a safe and reliable water supply in any residential or commercial property. A damaged or broken water line can lead to various issues, from low water pressure and leaks to contaminated water and even property damage. As such, addressing any water line issues promptly and effectively ensures your water supply’s continued safety and functionality.

The Advantages of Hiring a Professional Repair Service

Hiring a professional water line repair service is wise for homeowners and businesses. Water line issues can lead to significant property damage and costly repairs. Enlisting professionals allows you to solve water line problems efficiently, safely, and with minimal disruption to your daily life. You will experience the following benefits:

Expertise and Experience

Professionals have years of experience and training in diagnosing and fixing various water line issues. Their expertise allows them to quickly identify the root cause of the problem and determine the most effective solution. This ensures that the repair is done correctly first, preventing further damage and saving you time and money in the long run. Tioga Plumbing & Electric has experienced personnel to handle your repairs.

Advanced Equipment and Techniques

Professional companies have access to advanced tools and equipment that enable them to perform repairs efficiently and with minimal disruption to your property. They also stay up-to-date with the latest industry techniques and best practices, ensuring their work is of the highest quality and adheres to all relevant safety standards.

Comprehensive Services

An expert can handle various issues, from minor leaks to major breaks and blockages. This means you can rely on them to address any water line problem, saving you the hassle of searching for multiple contractors to handle different aspects of the repair.

Emergency Services

Many professional companies offer 24/7 emergency services, ensuring that help is available. This can be crucial in minimizing damage and preventing further issues from arising, such as mold growth or structural damage due to water infiltration. Tioga Plumbing & Electric are available to local clients any time they need water line repair.

Preventative Maintenance

In addition to addressing existing issues, experts can provide preventative maintenance to help you avoid future problems. This may include regular inspections, cleaning, and maintenance of your water lines and recommendations for upgrades or replacements when necessary.

Cost-Effective Solutions

By addressing issues promptly and effectively, you avoid costly long-term repairs. Additionally, professionals can often identify and fix problems quickly, preventing further damage and expense.


Repairs can be dangerous if improperly handled, posing risks to your property and health. Professional technicians are trained in safety procedures and equipped with the necessary protective gear, ensuring the job is done safely and without risk to you or your family. Tioga Plumbing & Electric ensures the safety of its clients by offering quality services.

Compliance with Local Regulations

Professional repair services are familiar with local building codes and regulations, ensuring their work is compliant and up to standard. This way, you can avoid potential issues with insurance claims in the event of damage.

Warranty and Guarantees

Many professional companies offer warranties and guarantees, providing peace of mind and assurance that the job has been done correctly. This can also save you money if repairs are needed due to faulty workmanship or materials.

Time Savings

Hiring a professional can save you time and effort, as they can quickly diagnose and address the issue. This gives you enough time to focus on other tasks and responsibilities rather than spending your time attempting to fix the problem yourself.

Reduced Stress

Dealing with water line issues can be stressful, particularly if you are unsure how to address the problem or are concerned about potential damage to your property. Hiring an expert can alleviate this stress, as you can trust that the issue will be resolved quickly and effectively.

Improved Water Quality

Professional services can help improve water quality by addressing leaks, blockages, and contamination. This can positively impact your health and well-being, as well as the overall performance of your plumbing system.

Environmental Benefits

Promptly addressing water line issues can help to conserve water and reduce waste, contributing to a more sustainable and environmentally friendly home or business. This can also help you save on water bills and reduce your environmental footprint.

Essential Maintenance Tips for Extending the Lifespan of Your Water Line

Water piping is essential in any residential or commercial plumbing system, availing water for use. Maintaining these lines ensures their longevity and prevents costly repairs or replacements. By following a set of essential maintenance tips, you can extend the lifespan of your water line and enjoy an uninterrupted water supply for years to come.

Regular Inspections

Scheduling routine inspections of your water line is the first step in ensuring its longevity. A professional plumber can identify potential issues, such as leaks, corrosion, or blockages before they escalate into more serious problems.

Sediment Removal

Sediment buildup can cause blockages and reduce water flow in your water line. To prevent this, install a sediment filter at the main water supply to trap and remove sediment before it enters your water line. Regularly clean or replace the filter to maintain optimal water flow and prevent sediment buildup. 

Pipe Replacement

Pipes may be beyond repair. In such cases, replacing the affected section of the water line can help extend its overall lifespan. Consult a professional plumber to determine if pipe replacement is necessary and to ensure proper installation.

Professional Maintenance

Regular professional maintenance is essential for keeping your water line in optimal condition. A licensed plumber can perform thorough inspections, identify potential issues, and provide expert advice on maintaining your water line. Schedule routine maintenance visits to ensure the longevity of your water line.

Are you experiencing issues with your water line? Don’t wait until it’s too late! Contact our company, Tioga Plumbing & Electric, today for expert water line repair services. Our experienced professionals will diagnose the problem and provide efficient and effective solutions to get your water line up and running in no time. Call us now, don’t let a damaged water line disrupt your daily routine. 

See our most recent blog on this topic here.

Photo By Ivan-balvan at iStock
5 Signs It’s Time to Schedule an Appointment for Water Heater Repair

5 Signs It’s Time to Schedule an Appointment for Water Heater Repair

The water heater is one of the appliances designed to make living in your house more comfortable and convenient. The appliance is always working hard behind the scenes to make hot water available to your family all the time. However, the water heater, like other appliances, can break down, fail to do its work as expected, and even put your family and house in grave danger. Unfortunately, considering the importance and sensitivity of residential water heaters, most water heater issues you will run into will need to be addressed as soon as they have been spotted. Indeed, failure to address water heater problems promptly could cause the problems to worsen and end up costing you more to fix. Besides, continuing to run a broken water heater could put your family at risk of getting seriously hurt. Therefore, you need to have a professional plumbing contractor you can call any time you notice a warning sign of a water heater failure. But what exactly can make it necessary for you to call a professional water heater repair service? Below is a rundown of the common signs of a water heater failure.


Since the role of your water heater is to heat water, the lack of hot water in your house is perhaps the most obvious sign of water heater failure. Many issues can cause your water heater not to heat water as expected. For instance, if its pilot light assembly has malfunctioned, gas will not get ignited as expected, and therefore, the water heater coming from your water heater will be cold. The issue might also be caused by issues like broken heating elements and a malfunctioning thermostat. Whatever the underlying cause of the problem might be, you can count on a professional water heater repair expert to help you diagnose it and come up with the best solution to restore the supply of hot water in your house.


Of course, you expect the water coming from your water heater to be clean and clear. Therefore, if your hot water is not as clear as the cold water, then you have a legitimate reason to be concerned. In most cases, the discoloration of hot water from your water heater is caused by rust. Rust in water heaters usually occurs as a result of the deterioration of the anode rod. This is the component that is designed to change the chemical status of the water in your water heater with the aim of reducing the rate of corrosion. However, with time, the anode rod might wear out and lose its effectiveness, causing the water heater to rust. If nothing is done to fix the issue properly, your water heater might quickly get corroded and start leaking. Therefore, when notice that the water coming into your house is discolored, you need to make an immediate call to your plumbing contractor. Your plumber will assess the condition of your water heater to see the extent of corrosion and determine if the issue can be fixed by replacing the anode rod or you will need to get your water heater replaced.


Your water heater does not necessarily run entirely silently. When it is working normally, you might hear the sound of boiling water in it. However, unless your water heater is broken, its natural sound should not be bothersome. Therefore, if you have noticed strange sounds coming from the appliance, it could be broken. Different water heater sounds may point to different issues. For instance, if your water heater is producing a hissing sound, the underlying cause of the problem could be a small leak or excessive pressure. On the other hand, popping or cracking water heater sounds are usually associated with a huge buildup of sediments in the water heater. The good news is that professional plumbing contractors are familiar with such unusual water heater sounds, and it will be much easier for them to pinpoint and fix their underlying causes.


When your water heater is working optimally, it should be giving you adequately heated water. Therefore, if you have noticed that the water coming from your water heater is not hot enough, you have a legitimate reason to be concerned, and you should consult a professional water heater repair service provider. Some of the reasons your water heater might give you tepid water include a broken thermostat and malfunctioning heating elements. Your professional plumbing contractor should help you with diagnosis and the necessary repairs.


Under normal circumstances, no water should be leaking from your water heater. Therefore, the area around the appliance should be fairly dry. As such, if you have noticed water pooling around the appliance, it could be leaking. Unfortunately, if the issue is not fixed on time, the leaking water could potentially hurt your pets and children, especially if it is too hot. Besides, the leaking water might create dampness that could welcome a mold infestation, which might compromise your indoor air quality and put the structure of your home in danger. Therefore, any signs of water heater leaks leaks should be addressed by a professional water heater repair service before they can get out of hand. 


As you can see, there are many signs of water heater failure that can make it necessary for you to make a quick call to your plumbing contractor. Failure to get these issues resolved promptly could cause the problem to get worse and cost you more to fix. Some of these problems might also put your home and family in danger if not addressed promptly. If you are looking for a reliable plumbing contractor to help you address any water heater issue you might run into, Tioga Plumbing & Electric is an excellent choice. We have been handling water heaters for a long time, and our reputation is above board. Call us today for more information about our company and services.

See our most recent blog on this topic here.

Photo By Zeybart at iStock
The Role of a Plumbing Company in Health and Safety

The Role of a Plumbing Company in Health and Safety

Clean, safe drinking water, hygiene, and sanitation are crucial to human health and well-being. While humans can survive for three weeks without food, they can only go for three to four days without water. Water is a primary necessity, without which we cannot survive. According to the director of WHO, safe water, sanitation, and hygiene shouldn’t be a privilege for only those in rich or urban centers.  

Role of Plumbers in Ensuring These Basic Needs Are Met

A plumbing company is crucial in ensuring communities and homes access clean water and proper sanitation. They are responsible for installing, repairing, and maintaining the plumbing system comprising pipes, fixtures, and appliances. These companies are also responsible for installing water treatment and filtration systems to eliminate water contaminants and ensure the water quality meets the required standards. 

Plumbers are also responsible for preventing cross-contamination between waste and clean water. This helps avoid the spread of diseases. In addition to ensuring there is access to clean water, plumbers also play a crucial role in proper sanitation. They are responsible for installing and maintaining sewage disposal and treatment systems. These processes help ensure the safe removal and treatment of wastewater, preventing disease spread and safeguarding public health.  

What Are the Risks of Poor Plumbing?

When poorly handled, plumbing can produce undesirable effects. Poor plumbing affects your home aesthetically and jeopardizes the health of your loved ones. If you fail to reach out to a reputable plumber promptly, dealing with the consequences of poor plumbing will cost you more money.

Here are some risks of poor plumbing:

Clogged drains

This is the most visible sign of lousy plumbing, especially if you recently had a plumbing job. Not only are clogged drains nasty to look at, but they are also a health hazard. It’s important to address the issue as soon as it arises. Typically, the main culprits of clogs are hair, plants, grease, and foreign objects. 

Contaminated water

A plumbing system comprises two pipes known as freshwater pipes and sewage pipes. Water from one system should never enter the other. Water contamination poses dangerous health risks and causes diarrhea, dehydration, stomach pains, eye, and skin irritation. There’s also a possibility of long-term effects such as infections and poisoning. Since water contamination may not be visible to the naked eye, paying attention to the color and smell of your faucet water is important. 


Mold is the worst thing that can happen due to poor plumbing. Small, consistent plumbing leaks can lead to mold growth in your walls. It can grow on walls, pipes, and household items. When inhaled, mold may cause respiratory problems and allergic reactions. If there is increased mold sighting in your house, it’s a sign you have water leaks. 


Some small plumbing leaks can quickly become disasters. A burst pipe can quickly cause flooding. This often leads to damaged floors, furniture, and other valuable possessions. Dealing with water damage can be challenging as it is expensive to replace the damaged property and restore the integrity of your property. In such cases, you need the help of a reputable plumbing company.      

Ways of Ensuring There’s Clean Water

Adopting effective water filtration systems is an effective way of ensuring there’s clean water for everyone. Since impure water is highly risky, the demand for filtration systems has also increased. 

Here are a few reasons why water filtration systems are important:

  • They remove harmful contaminants such as bacteria and viruses from the water. This process ensures water is safe to drink and reduces the risk of spreading waterborne diseases.
  • Filtration improves water’s taste and smell by eliminating pesticides, chemicals, chlorine, heavy metals, and bacterial contaminants. This process makes it more enjoyable to consume water.
  • It protects plumbing systems and appliances that water contaminants can damage. Water treatment and filtration systems increase the lifespan of your water heaters, washing machines, and dishwashers. 
  • It also helps with environmental protection as fewer pollutants are discharged into waterways, which helps preserve aquatic life and natural habitats. 

Plumbing Codes and Regulations

Codes and regulations govern plumbing practices and systems at the local, state, and national levels. These standards ensure public health and safety. They also govern rules for plumbing installation, maintenance, and repair. Some laws governing plumbing to safeguard public health and safety include the International Plumbing Code (IPC), National Standard Plumbing Code (NSPC), Uniform Plumbing Code (UPC), State and local codes, environmental Protection Agency (EPA) and Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA).

Plumbers are responsible for designing, installing, maintaining, and repairing plumbing systems following these codes and regulations to ensure public health.                                                                                                                                                                                 

How Can Plumbers Ensure There’s Clean Water and Proper Sanitation?  

Plumbers can help ensure clean water and sanitation through regular maintenance and repair of plumbing systems to prevent health problems from arising in communities. Regular repair and maintenance can prevent small plumbing issues from becoming significant issues that cause a health risk. A plumber can also deal with issues such as mold growth, water damage, and sewage backups that put health and sanitation at risk. 

They also play a key role in ensuring proper home sanitation by installing, maintaining, and repairing sewage disposal and treatment. Plumbers are also responsible for following plumbing codes and regulations that ensure the safety and health of the community. Failure to comply with these plumbing codes and regulations leads to legal liability, fines and penalties, property damage, and jeopardizing the health of communities. When hiring the services of a plumbing company, ensure they comply with these plumbing codes and regulations. 

Safeguard Your Health With the Help of Professional Plumbers

Clean water and sanitation are crucial for the public health and the well-being of communities. Plumbers play a critical role in ensuring this is possible through properly installing, maintaining, and repairing plumbing systems, including water filtration and sewage disposal and treatment systems. Homeowners and communities must prioritize clean water and sanitation by working with licensed and qualified plumbers to maintain and repair their plumbing systems. 

Tioga Plumbing & Electric is a leading residential and commercial plumbing company with over half a decade of experience. Not only do we guarantee our work, but we also thoroughly vet our technicians. Contact us today for any plumbing issues you may be facing.

See our most recent blog on this topic here.

Photo By lovelyday12 at iStock

Check out this tip!